The Science of Being Broke in College

Day 1 of the month: "I'll budget properly this time."

Day 15: "I can still make it work."

Day 25: "How much is my Paytm cashback?"

Day 28: "Does accepting money from juniors count as begging?"

Welcome to the universal experience of student poverty—a phenomenon that transcends colleges, cities, and income brackets. Let's analyze this condition with the seriousness it deserves.

---

The Monthly Financial Cycle: A Scientific Model

The Five Stages of Student Finances

     ABUNDANCE          COMFORT         CAUTION         SURVIVAL       CRISIS
       Day 1-5          Day 6-15       Day 16-22       Day 23-28      Day 29-31
         ↓                 ↓               ↓               ↓             ↓
    "Let's eat          "I can          "Maybe         "Maggi         "Who can
      out!"           afford this"      not today"      time"         I borrow 
                                                                      from?"

The Budget Reality

Expected Budget (What We Plan)

Actual Spending (What Really Happens)

---

The Mathematics of Student Poverty

The Meal Cost Hierarchy

Understanding where to eat based on current financial state:

The Maggi Dependency Index (MDI)

A scientific measure of financial health:

MDI = (Maggi meals per week) / (Total meals per week) × 100

MDI Interpretation:
├── 0-10%: Financially healthy
├── 11-30%: Normal student
├── 31-50%: Approaching broke
├── 51-70%: Officially broke
└── 71-100%: Intervention needed

---

The Psychology of "Small Expenses"

The Aggregation Blindness Problem

Students consistently underestimate spending because of small, frequent purchases:

This is literally half or more of most students' budgets—spent on things they don't even remember buying.

The "I Deserve This" Phenomenon

After any minor achievement, the brain rationalizes splurging:

The math: If you "deserve" things 10 times a month at ₹250 average, that's ₹2500—gone.

---

The Social Economics of Being Broke

The Birthday Problem

Mathematical analysis of friend birthdays:

If you have 15 close friends:

• Probability of birthday this month: 15/12 = 1.25 birthdays
• Average gift expected: ₹300-500
• Monthly birthday expense: ₹375-625

Add "treat culture" (birthday person treats OR friends treat):

• Additional expense: ₹200-400 per celebration

Annual birthday-related expenses: ₹4500-7000

Nobody budgets for this. Everyone gets hit by it.

The Group Outing Trap

"Let's split equally" is the most expensive phrase in student vocabulary:

"Let's split equally": You pay ₹200

You just paid ₹60 for other people's food. Multiply by 4 outings per month = ₹240 gone.

---

The Transport Economics

The Auto vs. Bus Dilemma

A daily calculation every student makes:

The decision tree:

Am I late? 
├── Yes → Auto (cost: ₹80)
└── No → 
    ├── Is it hot/raining? 
    │   ├── Yes → Auto (cost: ₹80)
    │   └── No → Bus (cost: ₹15)
    └── Am I tired?
        ├── Yes → Auto (cost: ₹80)
        └── No → Bus (cost: ₹15)

Reality: Students take auto 60% of the time, pay 4x the cost, and wonder where the money went.

The Fuel vs. Public Transport Calculation

For students with vehicles:

Public Transport Alternative: ₹800-1200/month

Savings: ₹2000-3500/month

Yet we choose vehicles. Why? Comfort, status, convenience. Expensive psychological needs.

---

The Food Economics Deep Dive

The "Mess Food vs. Outside" Calculation

Mess/Hostel Food:

• Monthly cost: ₹2500-3500
• Meals covered: All (30 days × 3 = 90 meals)
• Cost per meal: ₹28-39

Canteen/Outside Food:

• Average meal: ₹80-150
• If you eat out for 50% of meals: ₹3600-6750
• Plus missed mess fees: Still paying ₹2500-3500

Students who skip mess regularly spend 2-3x more on food.

The Ordering App Trap

The "order together" fallacy: Minimum order value forces you to add items.

You wanted ₹150 worth of food. Minimum order: ₹250. You ordered ₹280 "since we're so close."

---

The Survival Strategies: Ranked by Dignity

Tier 1: Preventive Measures

Tier 2: Reactive Measures

Tier 3: Emergency Protocols

---

The Parents' Perspective: What They Think vs. Reality

Monthly Transfer Assumptions

What parents think you spend on:

What you actually spend on:

---

The Financial Calendar: Key Expensive Dates

The "Festival Broke" Phenomenon

Every festival creates a spending spike that takes 2-3 weeks to recover from:

Diwali timeline:
Week -1: Shopping, gifts (₹2000 extra spent)
Week 0: Celebrations (₹1000 extra spent)
Week +1: Recovery mode (Maggi diet)
Week +2: Still recovering
Week +3: Normal spending resumes

Total Diwali financial impact: 4 weeks of irregular spending

---

The Saving Paradox

Why Students Can't Save

The problem: Any money "saved" becomes mentally "available."

Example:

• You budget ₹500 for entertainment
• You spend only ₹300
• You think: "I saved ₹200!"
• Next thought: "I can use this ₹200 for..."
• Result: ₹200 spent on something else

True savings only happen when money is physically moved somewhere inaccessible.

The ₹500 Rule

Most students can't explain where any given ₹500 went.

Ask yourself: "What did I spend my last ₹500 on?"

If you can't answer specifically, you have an awareness problem before a budgeting problem.

---

Solutions: Actually Practical Ones

The 50-30-20 Student Version

The key: Wants budget is FINITE. When it's gone, it's gone.

The Cash Diet

• Withdraw your weekly "wants" budget in cash
• Leave cards at home
• When cash is gone, spending stops
• Physically seeing money leave creates awareness

The 24-Hour Rule

For any non-essential purchase over ₹200:

1. Wait 24 hours before buying
2. If you still want it after 24 hours, buy it
3. Most times, you won't remember wanting it

---

Conclusion: Embrace the Broke

Being broke in college is:

• Universal (everyone goes through it)
• Temporary (you will earn eventually)
• Educational (you learn money management the hard way)
• Character-building (frugality is a skill)

The students who struggle financially often become the most financially aware adults.

So the next time you're calculating whether you can afford another chai, remember: you're not just managing money.

You're developing a superpower that'll serve you for life.

Now go—and maybe skip that chai. Your future self will thank you.

---

Being broke is temporary. The financial habits you build now are permanent.

---

Related Articles:

• The Psychology of College Attendance
• How Students Can Earn Money Using Only Skills